Can You Use Propane In A Butane Stove?
Propane and butane stoves use pressurized gas to put out a flame, and both these stoves and camping stoves require that the gas be “purged” before it can be used.
Purging can be done by dropping the pressure and letting the gas out (air pressure is the main component of the “burn” of a stove) or using a “purge valve” to let the gas out by opening a valve so it can flow out.
However; while camping, we mostly used stoves with either propane or butane. Now you might wonder if you can use propane on a camping gas stove, interchangeably?.
Yes, however; using propane on butane or interchangeably on camping stoves shouldn’t cause any issues, as they’re both byproducts of natural gas production, so it seems sensible that they’d be interchangeable. Although they are both classified as Liquefied Petroleum Gases (LPG), they are enough distinct to make swapping them risky.
As we all know that whenever you are on the go, that’s out of your kitchen at your home. The easiest way to prepare meals and also heat water is by using a camping stove.
However, it’s not news that the camp stove has always been a wonderful way-out for every camper going outdoor to explore nature, as well as if you’re on a fishing trip or hiking or hosting an event outdoors.
For the best camping stoves, it should at least allow you to explore your cooking and enjoy all hot and nutritious meals whenever you’re far away from your home. However, if you want to use propane on a butane camping stove, you must be very much careful and make sure you check the user guide on your stove.
Also, if you aren’t used to using a gas stove at home, using a camp stove could be quite frustrating for most campers who might be circumspect about using highly inflammable or other dangerous gases.
Propane vs Butane, “What you Need to Know Before Switching”
What do you need to know about propane or butane? They are both fuels for your camp stove. Both have many of the same benefits. Both have many of the same drawbacks.
Butane has a lower flashpoint. Butane has a lower boiling point. Butane has a lower storage capacity. Butane has a lower static vapor pressure. Butane has a lower concentration of carbon monoxide.
Butane has a lower odor. Butane is more flammable. Butane is more explosive. Butane has a lower energy density. Butane has a lower energy value.
However; for you to use propane on butane stoves, you just have to make sure you have the appropriate stoves for this, that is; a stove that could run on multi-fuel.
As we all know that the propane produces a very higher pressure, as well as contains enough energy to the cubic foot comparing to other natural gas.
However, for the fact that propane and natural gas are both fossil fuels, their densities are totally different, and as well possess total energy outputs differently.
Using propane in a natural gas stove might, or will work perfectly fine, but on the other hand, using a propane stove on natural gas will surely cause unnecessarily flame and this might not be safe for you.
“Note: many believe that, if you use natural gas with a propane appliance, you may cause a short flame, or you might have no flame.”
Afterward, there are stoves with a dual-fuel option, and most stoves with this option always come with at least two different ports. But for the orifices of natural gas, they are heftier than that of propane.
For natural gas, you will need enough space so as to allow a perfect flow of fuel, while the propane won’t support this because of its orifices, which are very small to that of natural gas stoves.
Also, for the high pressure and energy output, and as well for your safety, it’s advisable you use the right ports for the right fuel. As the pressure can pull off if installed wrongly.
“For better understating, there are camping stoves that support for both propane and natural gas, (and this is always stated in the stove’s description menu), however, if you have such stove, you will claim it’s impossible using the two fuel interchangeably”.
>> See also: How To Connect Gas Bottle To Camping Stove?
Can You Use Butane Gas On A Propane Regulator?
Propane and butane gas are the two most common cooking fuels in the U.S. If you’ve ever used a camping stove, you’ve probably used both. Propane is a clean-burning fuel that can be used to heat the contents of a stove.
Butane is similar to propane, but with a higher boiling point and a lower freezing point. It’s commonly used as a fuel for backpacking stoves for this reason.
For most stoves, either (small or big, single or double burner, portable or backpacking or grills), they all use high-pressure regulators which are also used to double the flame control.
“For disposable propane connecting to fit the inlet of the regulator. Also, there are adaptor hoses that can help you to connect for a bigger tank. The propane regulators have a very small gas orifice that will help reduce the amount of gas flow.”
Meaning, for any camping (stoves, burners, or grills), has its own integral regulator, which is designed to suit its needs. Asking if “can you use propane on a camping gas stove regulator” is also the same as asking if “can I use a propane regulator with butane”.
In the first instance, they can’t be used interchangeably, and why will you use propane on a camping gas stove regulator or stovetop. Whenever you have the regulator bad, just buy a replacement, and you can take that; that has bad for any nearby recycling center.
However, if you are camping with the Coleman grill or bbq, for these; Coleman has a standard regulator. But for camping stoves, it is unusual. Come to look at it this way, using another regulator won’t fit properly and will cause bad flames, as we all know that the normal flame on any gas stoves or (appliance) is blue.
However; I was recently camping with a friend, and this is what happened. In the morning, my friend came out of the tent to start breakfast. As she was preparing the coffee, she put down her pan to reach for a can of coffee. What I saw next shocked the hell out of me. She was cooking on a propane burner, and she had a can of butane gas sitting on a gas regulator. By the way, the burner had a welding glove sitting on it.
However, using it interchangeably will cause a yellow flame, meaning the flame is lacking some oxygen. (If your camping stove runs yellow flames, don’t worry we got you covered as we have written a post on how you can fix yellow flame on gas stoves, click here).
What Is the Difference Between Propane And Butane Regulator
What can you find in a propane and butane regulator? Are they the same product? Are they totally different? Yes, they aren’t the same thing. Let’s look at the main differences between propane and butane regulators:
A 29mm bar low-pressure regulator will be used with a 4.5kg butane gas bottle. When the black washer on a regulator is tightened, it forms a very gas-tight seal. While A 3.9kg propane cylinder, on the other hand, necessitates a screw-on regulator with an adjustable pressure range of 0.5—2 bar. However; it is very important to check to see if you have the correct regulator for your cylinder, whether it is propane or butane.
Butane gas regulators have lower pressure regulators than propane gas regulators. The primary distinction between the two is their boiling points. Propane burns at -42 degrees Celsius, whereas Butane has a much higher boiling point of -2 degrees Celsius. To avoid potential problems, make sure you have the correct regulator for your cylinder.
Butane vs Propane Safety Tips
At first, as have said earlier, that if at all you want to use propane in a natural gas stove, always check the manufacturers listing on your stove if they have rated for multi-fuel, such as using both propane and natural gas, this will save you time and street.
Propane and Butane are both commonly used as fuels for power tools and heating devices. Both are flammable and the potential for ignition exists, but each has unique characteristics that make it a potentially more dangerous fuel.
However, both can also pose a danger if one is not careful. By taking a few precautions, a user can reduce the chances of a butane or propane accident occurring.
When trying to make a propane conversion, it’s advisable you seek professional guidance before proceeding. For me, I will encourage you to just purchase a propane stove if you want to use propane, as it’s the safest, and truthfully, so as to avoid any risk.
>> See also: How long will a single butane cylinder last?
Tips, Guide For Using Propane On A Butane Stove
For most of us, we are only comfortable with our electrical stove at home, however; going camping for the first time with a propane camping stove will be problematic.
For this, we have help gathered some useful tips that will help you get the most out of your camping lifestyle and be able to explore nature with your favorite meals. Check out below:
- For the safest use, propane camping stoves should be outdoor only, (although I didn’t say you can’t use a camp stove inside your tent), you might experience a rainy day while camping, and you need to get your meal cooked, what will you do? You can just use your camp stove inside your tent. But you need to be very much careful with your propane gas camping stoves as it requires use in a well-ventilated area. (For more safety tips, you can check our post on using a camp stove inside a tent, click here).
- Keep your propane fuel canisters properly, in excellent condition, maybe you might not know, for every small propane canister, they are high pressure, and could get explode in an unusual condition. In other to avoid this risk, it’s advisable you store your propane bottles in a well-ventilated place, and always keep away from any kind of open flame.
- Always place your stove properly, never place your camping stove on the ground directly, because your stove needs air circulation so as to help you prevent any inflammable danger. However, during the winter, you shouldn’t use your stove on frozen earth, ice, or snow. For most camping stoves, if placed on a meltable object and this could lead to an unstable or topple condition.
>> See also: How long will a single butane cylinder last.
Propane Camping Stove Does it Really Matter?
It’s not news that whenever you’re on the go, they have rated propane camping stove as the best stove to get all your cooking done. For it has been an efficient camping fuel for a camp stove.
However, if you have to use the propane stove, you notice that the standard 1-lbs propane gas canisters are made to be a disposable tank, meaning it’s not refillable.
With this, disposing of an empty propane fuel tank can be an ambitious call for; many as it’s considered to be hazardous debris. That’s why most used propane fuel tanks always end up at the campgrounds or are dumped somewhere as waste.
However, if you refill a single-use bottle of propane, this could be somewhat perilous, and that is why most companies have suggested not to refill a single-use tank of propane.
Although we aren’t saying there is not a refillable propane tank, however; there is a refillable propane tank, just that it’s only available for an extra weight tank. As for car campers who love the propane camping stove can easily get a 5-lbs propane tank, with an adaptor hose to help you hook up with your camp stove. However, if you have a 5-lbs propane tank, you can easily refill it whenever you run out of fuel.
Can You Use Propane On A Natural Gas Stove?
It happens most time, that you have some leftover propane or any other natural gas, and you brought a new stove. For instance, you have a propane fuel, and you ordered a butane, or any other type of fuel stove falsely, you ask yourself, “are propane and natural gas interchangeable?”.
For most people, and considering the fact that the butane and the isobutane fuel is just a mix that works great for backpacking.
If you are among those asking whether they “can you use propane interchangeably”, I will just say YES! But this normally works perfectly for backpacking stoves, as some runs on but propane and isobutane and as well butane, due to the fact that normally they take a 1-lbs canister. Generally, most camping stoves that support a 1-lbs butane canister will surely support 1-lbs propane.
Meaning if have mistakenly brought a butane stovetop, while you have propane, it will still work just fine. Just that the butane and the propane cook and boil at different temperatures.
Asking about using propane on a camping gas stove interchangeably, this question is what we have been talking about. And as we all know that, propane is somewhat heavier than your natural gas.
However, if you want to use propane and natural gas interchangeably? You will only need to change the valves. With this, you can use your propane interchangeably on your natural gas camping stoves with no fear of it being combusted, as irregular combustion could lead to an explosion.
And lastly, using your appliances interchangeably also requires the right adapter. This is what determines the rate at which gas flows, as well will determine your stove’s energy output. Also for the propane, will be delivered at a higher pressure and the energy output will be higher.
However, your new camping stove comes with the right regulator installed, and if at all you need to use it interchangeably, make sure you do it the right way, and if you can’t handle this yourself, seek professional advice.
In end, you have several options when it comes to choosing a fuel source for your camping stove. Butane stoves are convenient because they are small and easy to use, but propane stoves are more powerful and have a wider range of options for fuel. So which fuel source is right for you?
However; camping with the right stove and fuel will make camping more fun as you will be able to explore your cooking experience. You might find it awful if you got the wrong stove or fuel as well.
Though, for most campers who have suggested that you can use propane for natural gas or butane camping stoves, afterward; in addition to this, it’s better you choose the right fuel for your stove. This will help you avoid any risk that may occur using your appliance interchangeably.